As a born and bred New Yorker I’m more than just a little picky when it comes to pizza. Since coming to school at Gettysburg, finding pizza has become that much harder… not many NYC style pizza joints in PA I guess huh? However, I recently discovered My Brother’s Pizza on Fairfield Rd about 2 miles away from the college campus.
“Brothers” (as it’s called by students) is situated in a strip mall right off Fairfield next to the Gettysburg Dance Center. While I can’t say that the pizza is as good as home, it is certainly close. The family that runs Brother’s is kind, thorough, and runs a very clean family friendly trattoria. There is plenty on their menu for fast, fresh American Italian and plenty of room to spread out with your friends. I would highly recommend getting the pizza, the subs, or the buffalo wings.
As far as I know they don’t deliver to the college, however the drive is more than worth it and is much better than the other pizza joints in town.
-My Brother’s Pizza –
1685 Fairfield Rd # A
Gettysburg, PA 17325-6953